Holey Terror: Hole No.12 at Pilgrim’s Oak

April 29, 2026
Holey Terror

Holey Terror: Hole No. 12 at Pilgrim’s Oak

Pilgrim’s Oak • Peach Bottom, PA • pilgrimsoak.com • 717-548-3011

Hole No. 12 • Par 3 • 192 Yards

Oftentimes, the best golf courses are the ones hardest to find. Pilgrim’s Oak, tucked away in southern Lancaster County, PA, is a prime example. There are no major towns nearby and to get there you have to share the road with John Deere tractors and Amish horse-and-buggys. But despite the directional challenges and solid-lined, no-passing lanes, the layout has become a favorite destination for both locals and traveling golfers, alike.

Designed by Dr. Michael Hurdzan, Pilgrim’s Oak is located in Peach Bottom, PA, a town you might not find on most AAA maps. But it’s here you’ll find a world-class 18-hole public venue which blends the subtleties of a classic links-style course with the bold design features of a modern stadium layout. Hurdzan’s philosophy of building courses that enhance, rather than distract from, their natural settings is on full display, as is his tendency to present risk-reward opportunities on just about every hole.

Holes 11-13 form Pilgrim’s Oak’s own version of Augusta’s “Amen Corner.” Of these three, it is the par-3, 192-yard No. 12 that qualifies as both the layout’s signature hole and its Holey Terror. Number 12 is played from a series of terraced tee boxes, over water and a rock basin, down to a large heart-shaped green. There are no bail-out areas as the back of the green is protected by wetlands and the right side guarded by tall trees and two menacing bunkers. There simply is no room for error, with the hole playing just as tough from the white and gold tees (160 and 101 yards).

Ranked as one of the top public courses in Pennsylvania, Pilgrim’s Oak offers just about every challenge imaginable – dramatic elevation changes, all types of natural hazards, plenty

Keep Reading

Holey Terror

Holey Terror: Hole No. 5 at Coyote Crossing

Coyote Crossing • West Lafayette, IN • coyotecrossinggolf.com • 765-497-1061

Hole No. 5 • Par 3 • 217 Yards

The first lesson in Golf Course Architecture 101 is that land should dictate design. So it’s no surprise that hall-of-famer Hale Irwin, one of the few players in history to win three U.S. Opens and a prodigious student of the game, would follow that rule to a “tee” at Coyote Crossing in West Lafayette, IN. The award-winning layout fits the property like a well-worn glove.

Coyote Crossing epitomizes Irwin’s design philosophy, […]

Holey Terror

Holey Terror: Hole No. 2 at Royal New Kent

Royal New Kent • Providence Forge, VA • royalnewkent.com • 804-966-7023

Hole No. 2 • Par 5 • 605 Yards

Imagine, if you will, plucking up Royal County Down or Ballybunion by their roots and transplanting them — bunkers, dunes and fescue included — to a 282-acre plot of land just 20 or so miles west of Williamsburg, VA. Do that and you’ll have an idea as to what Royal New Kent is like. The course is a testimony to architect Mike Strantz’s vision 30 years ago to […]

Holey Terror

Holey Terror: Hole No. 17 at Mill Quarter Plantation

Mill Quarter Plantation • Powhatan, VA • millquarter.com • 804-598-4221

Hole No. 17 • Par 5 • 580 Yards

All too often it’s the new breed of golf courses that attract the lion’s share of the publicity. Admittedly, the attention is well-deserved as many of the layouts that have opened in the past few decades feature some of the most innovative ideas in course design. But for many golfers, a round on one of the traditional layouts drawn by pencil and a straight ruler in the 1960s and ‘70s can be […]